Sorry for the late update, a day after the trip to the dealership I came down with that nasty flu/cold/stomach virus/plague that seems to have been going around (at least, it is here). But to the point, they got the scuff out no problem, and they had a few of their technicians drive the car to try and figure out the chirp/squeak I was hearing and they said they couldn't replicate it. So, I've kind of chalked that up to me just being a budding manual driver. Along the way to the dealership though I noticed the vent bezel was bent down on the left vent. They couldn't explain it or fix it readily so they ordered me a whole new bezel, hopefully it will be a direct fit.