i think you would still be happy, but like said in an earlier post, you have to remember it's a different kind of vehicle. i traded in a modified trailblazer ss(most people think it's just a "pimped out" suv) giving up around 300hp and all wheel drive.
the other day i was out cruisin in my sonic on some open stretches. it was the first time really running it some, and i was pretty dissapointed when i saw how it started struggling just to hit upper double digits, let alone triple... my tbss would see triple without an effort. However, i took some twisty back roads home and couldn't keep a smile off my face.
The sonic really is fun to drive and impressive, but just in a different way than you'll be use to. sounds like in your situation it will be a good fit, and you'll love the mileage. i know i was when i saw about a 20mpg jump from what i was use to!! :banana:
oh, and i have the 1.4T HB, with just an intake and shifter bushings, lol. can't wait for a tune since it's makes such a big change