wingman
Active member
You're CRAZY!!!!! You asked for it! But I do agree! :banana:
Adding an Oil Catch Can/Accessing your Tophats
- Thread starter Danny5
- Start date
You're CRAZY!!!!! You asked for it! But I do agree! :banana:
RichieRocket
New member
Gimpster, not sure if you are crazy or not
, but it looks like most car manufacturers disagree with you. Most have systems to reuse the oil to minimize oil consumption. The oil that you recover is mist that was squeezed out from tight clearance parts or sloshed up by the crank whipping around. You are right that piston ring blow-by has traces of unburnt fuel and water vapor. The main difference is the water and fuel are evaporated into a gas mixed with the air, the oil is in tiny atomized droplets of LIQUID oil suspended in the air. So when the engine and AOS system are up to operating temp, a properly designed AOS will collect the oil mist into drops and the water and fuel vapor will go right thru the AOS to get reingested into the intake.
Some of the aftermarket AOS return the oil:
Crawford Performance
GrimmSpeed
Even airplane engines return the oil, if anyone was concerned about oil quality, I would hope airplane guys do
M-20 News
"The water vapor and the air flow straight through, but the oil clings to a variety of collecting surfaces, forms into droplets and returns to the engine"
Gimpster
New member
Remember that manufactorers are beholden to emissions laws, thus why they're recirculated into the engine in the first place. Not to mention they can't use vented catch systems etc. If you took a time machine back a few decades you'd see every car had a "road tube" that literally just blew crank case emissions to the ground. In fact, my 2001 Dodge Ram does this... and they did until 2004 I think (heavy trucks were exempt from a lot of stuff until not long ago).
Either way pull the intake off any car thats been on the road a long time, and how it SHOULD be and how it REALLY looks are two different things.
http://www.audizine.com/gallery/data/500/medium/Before15.jpg
Excessive case, but you get the point... and it differs from car to car.
Just my humble opinion.
Either way pull the intake off any car thats been on the road a long time, and how it SHOULD be and how it REALLY looks are two different things.
http://www.audizine.com/gallery/data/500/medium/Before15.jpg
Excessive case, but you get the point... and it differs from car to car.
Just my humble opinion.
RichieRocket
New member
Gimpster, looks like we are talking about different things. My note was about sending the oil from the AOS back into the engine. Sounds like you are talking about where the air goes after oil mist is separated out
On your Cummins deisel, does it have a vent tube running down to the ground? Or is the vent unit sitting on top of the valve cover? If it vents inside, your vent must have some kind of filter or metal mesh to captures the oil mist so it can drain back into the engine, otherwise you would have oil mist coating the entire inside of the engine compartment...
On your Cummins deisel, does it have a vent tube running down to the ground? Or is the vent unit sitting on top of the valve cover? If it vents inside, your vent must have some kind of filter or metal mesh to captures the oil mist so it can drain back into the engine, otherwise you would have oil mist coating the entire inside of the engine compartment...
Gimpster
New member
No I think we're talking about the same thing? I'm saying I want zero of the oil that comes out of the breater captured in the AOS back into my engine. If the engine didn't want it, I don't want it.
And CORRECT, the Cummins is coated in oil (along with the rest of the undercarriage) just like cars of olden days. The tube comes out of the front of the cam chain case, heads straight down to a bottle thats SUPPOSED to capture the mist. It doesn't go back into the engine, you're supposed to clean it out now/then. However it of course doesnt capture a darn thing and just blasts the engine, radiator and undercarriage with nasty stuff. On the plus side, I know my floor boards won't rust
http://cf.mp-cdn.net/a6/ca/4e00a34d3c5900f1a28f0d28936c.jpg
You can see it in that picture, its the round thing on the front with the hose just pointed to the ground lol.
And CORRECT, the Cummins is coated in oil (along with the rest of the undercarriage) just like cars of olden days. The tube comes out of the front of the cam chain case, heads straight down to a bottle thats SUPPOSED to capture the mist. It doesn't go back into the engine, you're supposed to clean it out now/then. However it of course doesnt capture a darn thing and just blasts the engine, radiator and undercarriage with nasty stuff. On the plus side, I know my floor boards won't rust
http://cf.mp-cdn.net/a6/ca/4e00a34d3c5900f1a28f0d28936c.jpg
You can see it in that picture, its the round thing on the front with the hose just pointed to the ground lol.
RichieRocket
New member
Thank goodness all the cars on the road don't puke out oil like that, we wouldn't be able to breathe These new fangled PCV systems are new technology, cars have only had them since the mid 60's Do these systems sometimes fail when they get old, sure, but I don't think that means they should all be removed...
I wrote in an earlier post that oil from a "properly designed" AOS which operates at warm temperature, will collect only the atomized liquid oil droplets and let the water and fuel vapor pass right thru with the air flow. For water to condense out, it has to have a cool surface. The oil, which is not contaminated with water or fuel can flow back to the oil pan. Many cars do it, no problem...
Your down tube with bottle is not the same thing. The bottle is cool, so of course water and fuel vapors will condense out and contaminate the oil. I would not re-use that oil either!
These new fangled PCV systems are new technology, cars have only had them since the mid 60's Do these systems sometimes fail when they get old, sure, but I don't think that means they should all be removed...I wrote in an earlier post that oil from a "properly designed" AOS which operates at warm temperature, will collect only the atomized liquid oil droplets and let the water and fuel vapor pass right thru with the air flow. For water to condense out, it has to have a cool surface. The oil, which is not contaminated with water or fuel can flow back to the oil pan. Many cars do it, no problem...
Your down tube with bottle is not the same thing. The bottle is cool, so of course water and fuel vapors will condense out and contaminate the oil. I would not re-use that oil either!
Thaifight-R
Pika Pii!!!
So I ended up getting rid of my can before I had the chance to install it on my Sonic.
Probably gonna order another one soon. haha
How's yours holding up so far?
Probably gonna order another one soon. haha
How's yours holding up so far?
rdss
Junior Member
Did you read the very first post?! It kind of has a really good "how to".
sonic hotness
New member
This is a very good mod to do.
sonic hotness
New member
Huh?
laborsmith
New member
An oil catch can is definitely needed on a direct injection engine.
Using one on a non direct engine is only needed for show.
Laborsmith
Using one on a non direct engine is only needed for show.
Laborsmith
sonic hotness
New member
Just got a catch can for $20 this same one but mines is silver.
RS Turbo
New member
Direct Injections engines put fuel directly in the cylinders, port injected engines spray the fuel at/on/around the intake valve so the oil vapor is washed into the cylinders and burned. This does not happen with direct injected engines so the oil build up causes deposits on the intake valve and manifold and start to gum up over time.
Inferno
New member
Ok first off any car with an active Pcv is going to gum up as you say. In theory a turbo car will befor a na car. The vacum created by the intake is just suckin the life out of the block like my last girlfriend. The less than two inch span of where the fuel come in makes no diferance. Any motor with a Pcv is going to get oil deposits in it with out a catch can. I have had more motors in prices than I've seen boobs and at two a set that's alot.
rdss
Junior Member
What oil catch can are you running?!......